Jul 19 2007
The Delusions of the Last Rightwing Remnant: Freerepublic.com
Cyrano’s Journal Online, Thomas Paine’s Corner, The Greanville Journal, CJO Avenger, and VoxPop are initiating a weekly email which will include links to the latest high quality content available on our very diverse and comprehensive site. If you would like to subscribe, type “CJO subscription” in the subject line and send your email to
Originally published by The Rec Report / Citizens for Legitimate Government
By Michael D. Rectenwald, Ph.D.
7/19/07
Only a small minority in the United States maintains an unwavering faith in the administration of George W. Bush. Most of the country has finally discovered Bush and his ilk are liars, thieves, incompetent hacks, and mercenary madmen. Only a few true believers remain. These few are reflected in the unwavering statistical minority of 30%-33%, who still support Bush, and apparently will support Bush, no matter what he does. This remnant, or as Steven Colbert called them, “the backwash,” will never sway. Like the Christian martyrs of old, they will go to their deaths swearing allegiance to their master. One might wonder who this faithful remnant is, and just where its members might be found. Well, a narrow and vociferous margin can be found screeching on Freerepublic.com. There, they are apparently alive, but judging from what they hold to be ‘reality,’ not so well.
On Freerepublic.com, we find those who still believe in the Bush agenda: the war, the insurgency, the domestic agenda, and yes, even in the reliability of the Bush propaganda machine. Here we find the few who find no irony in the language of the Bush regime. They see nothing ironic about the fact that the original name for the war in Iraq was Operation Iraqi Liberation, the acronym for which is O.I.L.–that is, before it was changed to cover up the inauspicious and inadvertent revelation of its true purpose. They see no irony in the idea of liberating a country from a dictator, and then using his former prisons to torture its citizens. They see no irony in calling the ‘enemy’ ruthless killers, even as they have bombed and ruthlessly killed many times more people than the enemy. They see no irony in trumpeting a war against terrorism, even as their state terrorism has precipitated a bloody civil war that has drastically added to terrorism’s ranks. They see no irony in the fact that they no longer know who the enemy is, and instead hope to secure the enemy from the enemy’s enemy. They see no irony in the administration’s demands that Iran not “interfere” in the affairs of Iraq. They see no tragedy in the report that over 2 million former Iraqis are now refugees in nearby countries and another 2 million are now homeless inside Iraq. They see no irony in the fact that Bush now claims a need to stay in Iraq, lest it become the safe-haven for terrorism that he claimed it was before he attacked, but which it has only become since he attacked. They see no irony in decrying the supposedly undemocratic regimes in Venezuela and elsewhere, even as their own elections have been notoriously and egregiously flawed, indeed probably rigged, so much so that human rights watch groups would refuse to monitor them. They see no irony in their “pro-life” agenda, even as they kill tens of thousands of innocent, walking and talking children and adults. They see no irony in the fact that the latest media spokesman for the regime is named “Tony Snow,” as if an admission that the message delivered will be part of a “Snow job.”
No, their belief in Bush persists, despite so much evidence to contradict it. The supernatural basis of this faith is the key to its persistence. Like Panglossian believers against contrary evidence, they retain faith in a political ideology that they imagine to be flawless, regardless of its increasingly deleterious emanations. And what do they say to anyone, especially anyone with a message and the determination to voice it, who disagrees? Here, they do not act so much like the good-natured Pangloss.
For one, they attack the credibility of anyone who attacks their fearless leader. I myself have been a recent target of their vituperative denunciations, which, if they weren’t so vitriolic and suggestive of violence, would be hilarious for their sheer boorishness and desperate flailing. They claim, erroneously, that I am not a real Ph.D., or that I am not a real professor of English. To prove this, they cite outdated documents showing me to be a Post-Doctoral fellow (which requires a Ph.D., incidentally), much like their leader’s use of outdated intelligence in the run-up to war. Little do they know that I have moved on from Carnegie Mellon University, where I worked as an editor for the Robotics Institute and a Post-doctoral Fellow for the English Department, and now hold a tenure-track position as an Assistant Professor, somewhere in the Carolinas? I say “somewhere in the Carolinas,” because the Freerepublic.com site is rife with criminally-minded cyber-thugs with the ethics of their leader. They are domestic terrorists who would stop at nothing to ruin the opposition. If it weren’t for the fact that the government is being run by like-minded criminal thugs, their threats would surely lead to investigations. To date, I have received dozens of death threats and other cowardly missives of warning. My previous address has been published, as has a list of my referees. Their tactics are infamous and their ethics deplorable. And they call me the fascist.
Meanwhile, I argued that for reasons that have become apparent, contemporary Republicanism is now a dangerous ideology that threatens the well-being of the planet. In this sense, I compared it to other dangerous political ideologies that should not be sanctioned under the liberal terms of ‘tolerance,’ such as Nazism and the white supremacist KKK. I cited the well-known Frankfurt School theorist, Herbert Marcuse, in support of my point. A poster on Freerepublic.com suggested that I’d never read the essay by Marcuse, or Marcuse’s other writings, at all. That would be anomalous, since I studied the Frankfurt School in great depth in graduate school, received an A in seminars, and included the Frankfurt School on my Ph.D. thesis exam. I also suggested that Bush and Cheney and other operatives in the war, as war criminals, belong in jail. Two days after I made this statement, an official of the International Criminal Court declared that he could envisage circumstances under which Blair and Bush could be brought before the court and tried for the coalition war crimes in Iraq. The email replies from “freepers” included attacks for my lack of concern over national sovereignty. To this charge, I plead guilty; national sovereignty should never be used to protect convicted or convictable war criminals. (Yes, my use of the semi-colon is proper here, as before.) Patriotism is the last refuge of the scoundrel. I do not respect its protection of the scoundrel, nor do I share the fanatical freeper concern about the black helicopters and the “evil” U.N. (Many months ago, I suggested on MSNBC’s “Scarborough Country” that Bush’s reason for eschewing the ICC was indeed because he knew that he could later be convicted for war crimes that he was soon about to commit).
After the publication of my “10-Points” article, freepers (irrelevantly) questioned my sexual preferences (”I bet this guy is gay”), attacked my grammar (especially ironic coming from the ‘is-my-children-learning’ rightwing), and raised doubts (in their minds) about my academic credentials. My fathering of three children and living with a beautiful dancer and choreographer (a woman) should put the questions about my sexual preferences to rest, as if such preferences mattered. Apparently they do to the freepers. Sorry, boys. Incidentally, these doubts were raised in connection to my teaching of ‘feminism,’ which these boors equate with femininity. They assume that anyone who studies feminism is either lesbian or gay. I suppose that all the first-wave suffragettes were lesbians as well. If so, the women amongst their contingent owe a great debt to lesbianism.
As to my academic credentials, earning a Ph.D. from a top twenty-five-ranked, internationally renowned university apparently disqualifies me for the freepers. Writing and publishing dozens of articles for the Robotics Institute’s Artificial Intelligence Lab also somehow disqualifies me in their minds. Some have even likened Robotics itself to idiocy. Meanwhile, I would take the artificial intelligence of software robots to the so-called natural intelligence of the freeper, any day. Freepers prefer anything to education, especially Liberal Arts and Humanities education. When they hear the word “culture,” they reach for their guns. Sound familiar? They attack anyone who can claim credentials beyond huckstering corporate garbage. It is not an accident that “liberal” and “education” are often juxtaposed.
The freepers suggest that in a subsequent Rec Report, I have ‘backtracked’ from my original “10-Point Plan,” because I am afraid that my having written it will somehow disqualify me from getting tenure. This charge is actually charmingly naïve. But, I should like to educate the Busheviks about something called “academic freedom,” which, unlike the freedumb (freedom to be dumb) avowed on Freerepublic.com, actually allows one to have a reasoned opinion that differs from that of the king-and-priest mob that stones dissenters. The reactionary mob has always been uneducated. This same kind of mob, incited by his sympathy for the French Revolution, burned down the house of English chemist and thinker, Joseph Priestly. This kind of mob included spies for the forces of oppression in England and elsewhere, finding “infidels,” “traitors” and “blasphemers” under every rock in the early 19th century. This same kind of mob has always opposed those who challenge the dominance of the few. This kind of mob has always been for reforms that have favored themselves-only if said reforms happened sometime in the past. This cowardly kind of mob reveres power and loathes future reform or change. They respond to contemporary ‘radicals’ as if they were devils, and meanwhile benefit from past radicals. This same kind of mob would have supported another idiot king named “George” against the revolutionary forces. In short, this same kind of mob has always worked against the best self-interests of its own individual members.
This same mob is a dangerous cabal with members that include dangerous, prominent politicians. I maintain that today, with critical worldwide issues at stake, their ideology is a serious bane to society and is prejudicial to the interests of a vast planetary majority. When I said that Republicans should be ‘thrown in jail,’ I referred only to those convicted of actual crimes. The fear on their part is that many are guilty. This includes Bush and Cheney, for starters, but also any other officials knowingly complicit in war crimes and other offenses, such as outing an undercover CIA agent. As for the low-level mobsters on Freerepublic.com, many should be tracked down by the police for any harassment, threats or actions taken to destroy others. They have proven my point every day since the 10-point plan was posted.
Dr. Rec, The Rec Report
Michael D. Rectenwald, Ph.D.
Permanent URL for this article:
http://www.legitgov.org/comment/rec_report_200307.html
The Rec Report Index
https://bestcyrano.org/cyrano/?p=105
A SPECIAL MESSAGE TO OUR READERS.
For over two years now, Thomas Paine’s Corner has been a powerful and unwavering voice for a courageous and badly needed agenda for change. We have consistently delivered hard-hitting and insightful commentary, polemics, and analysis in our persistent efforts to persuade, educate, and inspire, and serve as a discriminating but generous platform for voices from many points of view with one thing in common: their spiritual honesty and quality of thinking.
•
Aside from the caliber of its content, Thomas Paine’s Corner’s strength is that there are no advertisers or corporations to exercise de facto censorship or orchestrate our agenda. We aim to keep it that way and we need your help!
•
As a semi-autonomous section of the multi-faceted, thoroughly comprehensive, and highly prestigious Cyrano’s Journal Online, we share Cyrano’s passion for winning the battle of communications against systemic lies, an act which is essential to attaining social and environmental justice. To help us achieve that goal, Cyrano’s Journal, besides its regular editorial pages, intends to begin producing editorial videos to expose the lack of proper context, ahistoricalism, excessive over-emphasis on inane events, and outright lies the corporate media, and in particular television, present to you and your family as a steady diet of pernicious intellectual junk food. This will be an expensive under-taking and there will be no grants forthcoming from the likes of the American Enterprise Institute, the Coors or Heritage Foundation. You can be sure of that!
•
As Greek mythology has it, the powerful are frequently defeated by their own hubris, and that’s precisely what we are witnessing today. Our rotten-to-the-core, usurping plutocracy has become so overtly and arrogantly corrupt that our patience has now reached its generous limit, and the membrane of America’s collective consciousness is about to burst. This will result in a significant restructuring of our socioeconomic and political environments, we hope (and must make sure) for the better. Considering what is at stake in the world today, Cyrano’s Journal and Thomas Paine’s Corner want to accelerate the arrival of that new day, and its promise of a new, truly well organized, kind, and honest civilization.
•
Assisting us in our cause is as simple as clicking on the PayPal button below and exercising the power of your wallet. No matter how large or how small, we thank you in advance for your donation! If you are serious about our struggle for a new society, please don’t put it off. Let us hear from you today.
•Jason Miller
Associate Editor, Cyrano’s Journal Online, and Editorial Director, Thomas Paine’s Corner.
Patrice Greanville, Editor in Chief, Cyrano’s Journal Online
It’s Déjà vu, all over again, this time, against Iran. And again, the “aL-CIAduh” boogeyman is trotted out for all to see and fear.
Some of the same lies, distortions, half-truths and an American military build up in the Middle East, all with one goal in mine: To start the bombing campaign against Iran.
Although this time around, some of the media are a bit reluctant to go along with the agitprop being dished out.
They’re nervous bridesmaids, still a bit chafed that they bought all the lies and BS that led to the current illegal and immoral war against Iraq.
But they won’t wait long at the MIC/Zionist altar. The same echo-chamber that was so successful in selling the War against Iraq is being cranked up again. Slowly, the MSM, still blushing like the new bride it is, will open it’s mouth eagerly and quickly swallow WHOLE the treat that is being offered by their newest husband, the demented ZIOCONS.
Somewhere, there’s a budding Judith Miller, toiling away furiously, retyping pro war talking points as she carries out the goals of her masters, the ZIOCONS.
And let’s not forget Mr. Judith Miller, the idiotic and easily fooled NYT hack, Michael Gordon. Gordon does his master’s bidding exceedingly well, prepping the gullible American public for the next war of aggression.
P.S. Mikey, you can always tell your readers that the War against Iraq was a typo, it should have read War against Iran.
And there’s CNN, which like to boast it’s the best in the news business.
Which can be easily verified by the amount of time CNN always devotes to blonde bimbos, like Paris Hilton.
When AIPAC cracks the whip, CNN will jump on board even more than it already is and start selling this next war of aggression as “Us against Them.”
Us being the good guys in white hats and them, well, them is anyone Israel deems an obstacle to its goal of ME hegemony.
Soon, American troops will again be used as mercenaries for Israel’s dreams of ME domination.
A funny thing about corruption is that those who instigate corruption to serve their purpose underestimate the level of anarchy and paranoia that slip into the system.
So sooner or later the system fails due to incompetence of the decisions which are caused by the bad information which is a byproduct of this corruption, anarchy and paranoia.
Those Freeper idiots have been at it for years, smearing entire NATIONS of people.
The really ironic thing is that the sick freeper worldview leans more towards COMMUNISM than REPUBLICANISM!
The freepers are just a sick little bunch of cowards hiding behind their keyboards, worshipping Israel and US supremacy as if they actually benefit in some way from all their sychophantic cheerleading. They don’t benefit from Empire and neither does any American, except those in power.
Americans are catching on to the whole charade. Some have realized it before others have and more and more are coming to the realization that America is lost and it’s government doesn’t serve it’s people any longer.
Leave the freepers to their fantasies. They’re becoming more and more irrelevant each passing day.
[…] The Delusions of the Last Rightwing Remnant: The Free Republic […]
How wonderful to read a literate, logically presented piece on the complete lack of logic (linear, consensus-reality logic) and hypocrisy of the Bush/Cheney regime. No screaming, no ad hominem shots - well, none that were unjustified or scatological - and nothing that wasn’t laid out in order and backed up or easily checked. In other words, just what any fence-sitters who can be swayed by reason would need to see; this ought to convince all both of ‘em… I’m referring here to your writing in general as well as just this piece.
Seriously, I enjoy your writing, and hopefully I can put it to use. I’ve had a running ah, call it a “discussion” with verve - with a cousin in Texas who believes that “George Bush is a Godly man”, and that “… he’s the greatest president this country has ever had.” I tend to look for the Dramamine before I read his emails. I’m probably just shaking my head too much as I read. He’s a former high school chemistry teacher (who thinks the world is 5-6,000 years old), retired from being a school principal for over a decade. I had the misfortune of attending that school for a semester while we were stuck there after a bad car wreck. Fortunately I recovered quickly, having been educated in California up until then. My cousin has had no such good fortune, however, and his critical faculties seem to have been cauterized, or maybe got shot off in the war, though I’m not sure he served (I did). No amount of evidence seems to matter to him: it’s all “cobbled together by the Liberal Conspiracy” to try to “discredit a Great Man”. He cherry-picks points to answer and completely ignores everything else. For instance, after I pointed out exactly what NCLB has been doing to an already-sabotaged school system, he replied that the voucher system was a fair way to run the system, and the people who didn’t like it wouldn’t be satisfied by anything. That was it - his answer to two and half typed pages.
So in short, thank you VERY much for a breath of fresh air! I needed that.
Ian
They’re FREEPERS, man. Get over it.
I can’t believe you wasted all that copy on Freepers.
Written like a two-finger typist.
Thanks, Ian, for your comments.
Although it is always pleasant to read a lefty rant against the sycophants of thuggery (in this case, the so-called Freepers), we might better spend our time asking how these poor, angry, delusional fools got that way (regardless of the reply “I can’t believe you wasted all that copy on Freepers”). What is the psychology of the Freeper, and can this disease be prevented (and I would assume that there is no cure).
John Dean took a shot at this with “Conservatives Without Conscience”, but one always suspects that Mr. Dean is still doing public penance for the first half of his life.
A thought: I believe that it is fairly well known that, as a rule, a denigrated and excluded minority tends to turn it’s shortcomings into assets, embracing certain aspects of their “culture” that have marked them as outsiders (perceived or actual). This sort of mechanism can have benign results, or, at the extremity of its arc, result in terrorism and suicide (when degradation, perceived or actual, is complete and “justice” unobtainable).
These certain aspects, in the case of Freepers, would seem to be ignorance and anger.
Poor little Freepers! Such sad monsters!
(I have noticed that some Fundamentalist groups really revel in the idea that “the world is against us” – a phrase in which they find pleasant self-vindication.)
Shall we extend kindness and forgiveness to the wretched, snarling pawns of the Powers That Be?
Hell, no! That’s no fun!
bartender: a most thoughtful and enriching comment for our discussion. Thank you. A book that tackles—brilliantly and from the inside—the psychology and mores of these hard-to-fathom folks is the recently released DEER HUNTING WITH JESUS, by Winchester, Va., native Joe Bageant, who also happens to be a senior contributing editor to Cyrano’s Journal/T Paine’s Corner. This is his bioblurb at this site:
“JOE BAGEANT IS WITHOUT A DOUBT ONE OF THE MOST INSIGHTFUL contemporary chroniclers of American culture, with an authoritative hook on the “red state” mentality. Born in Winchester, Virginia, Bageant was raised among folks for whom the Bible’s teachings were literal truth and The Rapture a welcome event. Escaping this early conservative formation has been a lifelong enterprise, but in the process Bageant has matured into an indispensable guide for a segment of the American population which, boasting amazing and often fiercely contradictory idiosyncrasies, continues to puzzle most political observers. As Joe himself puts it: “Died in 2000 when George Bush got elected … died along with 275 million other Americans … Plan to rise again from the dead when he is tossed out …maybe reincarnate as a Commie terrorist on Wall Street … maybe as a sex worker in Amsterdam … can’t decide … both have their advantages.”
Keep those comments coming.